
“Possible Love” (“Ganeunghan sarang”)
(South Korea/USA)
Metacritic (4/10), Letterboxd (2/5), Imdb.com (4/10), TMDB.com (4/10), Imdb.com critics review
#BrentMarchant #PossibleLove #SouthKorea #laidofflaborer #investor #documentary #LeeChangdong #exploitation #empathy #intention #corporaterestructuring #employeestrike #helpinghand #browbeating #graceanddexterity #economicdisparity #workingclass #rulingclass #independentfilmmaker #classdistinction #contrivance #hiddenmotivation #squarepeg #roundhole #flashback
It should go without saying that “intention” plays a major role in shaping a movie’s narrative, especially when it attempts to convey important political, economic and/or sociological messages. It’s also crucial that such sentiments are delivered deftly, eloquently couched in the plot and any associated metaphors, without browbeating the audience or stumbling through the flow of the story. But, when these elements aren’t coordinated with the proper grace and dexterity, the picture usually fails, falling all over itself in the process, as is the case in this latest offering from writer-director Lee Chang-dong. In an unusual (and largely ineffective) effort to make a bold statement about South Korea’s broad economic disparity between the working class and the ruling class, the filmmaker puzzlingly attempts to address this subject through the experiences of two very different married couples. When a major corporate restructuring leads to a protracted employee strike that eventually turns violent, it leaves devastating emotional and physical scars on the workers, both in their professional and personal lives. So it is for laid-off laborer Ho-seok (Sul Kyung-gu), whose severe trauma has left him broken, beaten and demoralized and largely under the care of his devoted but quietly unhappy wife, Mi-ok (Jeon Do-yeon). She does her best to help her husband, but her efforts often go ignored and unappreciated – conditions that, unfortunately, have been present in their relationship for some time, as seen in a series of flashbacks. But this couple is not the only one to have been so impacted by this dispute; many other workers and their spouses have experienced the same. And their plight has consequently caught the attention of independent filmmaker Ye-ji (Cho Yeo-jeong), who is chronicling their circumstances in a new documentary, with Mi-ok serving as a key interview source. The two women subsequently become good friends, routinely socializing together, joined by Ho-seok and Ye-ji’s wealthy investor husband, Sang-woo (Zo In-sung). However, given the couples’ significant economic differences, they seem an unlikely foursome, a scenario that, ever so coincidentally, conveniently serves as a perfect (albeit derivative) metaphor for the state of South Korea’s class distinctions at large. In light of that apparent contrivance, then, how genuine are the individuals’ and couples’ motivations supposed to be? For instance, can Ye-ji’s seeming efforts at empathy toward her new friends be trusted? Is her film project a genuine gesture to extend a sympathetic helping hand, or is it a veiled (albeit unconscious) act of exploitation? And where does her quiet, conspicuously vague husband with all his money fit into this scenario? What’s more, are the entanglements on display here based entirely on class and economics, or are other hidden motivations and desires involved given their respective personal circumstances? If this all sounds muddled, confusing and more than a little melodramatic, you’d be right. While the filmmaker tries mightily to make a meaningfully relevant statement through a less-than-obvious approach, the pieces of this convoluted puzzle just don’t mesh well at all. They feel forced together, an embodiment of the square peg-in-a-round hole principle. Moreover, the more apparent it eventually becomes what the filmmaker is attempting to do, the more obvious, predictable and even juvenile it becomes. Considering the picture’s woefully overlong 2:46:00 runtime, he takes his own sweet time about it, too, incorporating a wealth of redundant, extraneous, meandering material in the run-up to a wholly unsatisfying conclusion. And, if all that weren’t enough, “Possible Love” has to be one of the worst titles I’ve ever seen assigned to a movie (what does that have to do with labor relations and class distinction?). In the end, this feels like a film put together by committee. Either of the primary story threads by themselves may well have made for an engaging picture, but certainly not as the mismatched pairing that’s been thrown together here. Indeed, intention really does matter.


